A family member and an estate planning professional speaking with an older adult at a table

Someone in your family has asked you to help get their papers in order: a will, and perhaps a power of attorney and a personal directive. Then a harder question arrives. Is this person still able to sign? Asking it does not make you disloyal. But a helper’s job is not to decide whether someone has capacity. It is to make it easier for that person to decide, and to bring in professional help when the answer is unclear.

Start with the right question

Most people ask “does she have capacity?” as though it were a yes or no about a person. Capacity is specific to a decision and is judged when the decision is made. Someone who cannot manage a bank account may still decide who receives her jewellery.

Nova Scotia law starts from a presumption. Under the Adult Capacity and Decision-making Act, an adult may make his or her own decisions unless incapacity is clearly demonstrated (s. 4(a)). An adult is not incapable merely because a decision looks risky or unwise to someone else (s. 4(b)), and may communicate by any means that enables the adult to be understood (s. 4(c)).

What the Act means by capacity

Section 3(d) defines capacity as the ability, with or without support, to understand information relevant to making a decision, and to appreciate the reasonably foreseeable consequences of making or not making it. Section 3(s) describes support as help that is reasonably and practically available, including communication, interpretive, and administrative assistance. Someone who needs an interpreter, a hearing aid, extra time, or plain language may still have capacity.

Three documents, three different tests

A will. The Wills Act sets the formalities at s. 6: writing, signed at the end by the testator, before two or more competent witnesses present at the same time, with the signature made or acknowledged in their presence and the witnesses signing in the testator’s presence. A gift to one of those witnesses, or to a witness’s spouse, is void, but that does not make the whole will invalid, and the gift stands where there are two other competent witnesses to the will (s. 12). The mental test is not in the Act. It comes from the common law, usually described through Banks v Goodfellow (1870): the person must understand the nature of making a will and its effect, know generally what they own and who might reasonably expect to benefit, and be free of a disorder of mind that prevents them exercising their own will.

An enduring power of attorney. The Powers of Attorney Act sets its own test at s. 2A. A person is presumed capable, and is incapable only if unable to understand and appreciate the nature and effects of granting a power of attorney: their property and its approximate value, their obligations to dependants, what the attorney may do, the risks of mismanagement or misuse of authority, and that it can be revoked while capable but not once incapable (s. 2A(2)). Needing support does not by itself make a person incapable (s. 2A(3)). It must be signed, dated, and witnessed by two competent adults who are both present when the donor signs, and neither may be the appointed attorney, the attorney’s spouse, registered domestic partner or common-law partner, or a child of the attorney (s. 3(1)). A child of the donor is not disqualified merely because of that relationship.

A personal directive. The Personal Directives Act defines capacity as the ability to understand information relevant to making a personal care decision and to appreciate the reasonably foreseeable consequences of a decision or of no decision (s. 2(a)). Only a person with capacity may make one (s. 3(1)), and it must be written, dated, signed, and witnessed by one eligible adult witness who is not a delegate, a delegate’s spouse (including a registered domestic partner or common-law partner), a person who signs on the maker’s behalf, or the spouse of a person who signs on the maker’s behalf (s. 3(2), (3)). If someone else signs at the maker’s direction and in the maker’s presence, that person cannot be the delegate or the delegate’s spouse. Nova Scotia Health does not allow its staff to witness personal directives as a matter of its own policy. The Act itself does not disqualify health care providers.

The same person, on the same afternoon, may be able to do one and not another. A concern has to be considered document by document.

What the Act’s assessment framework is for

The Act’s court process is a representation order: an application asking the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia to appoint someone to make specified decisions for an adult who cannot make them. The application generally must include a capacity assessment report from an assessor (s. 5), who determines capability in respect of the matters assessed using observational and collateral information (s. 13).

Not everyone in an eligible profession is an assessor. Section 3(b) lists the eligible health professions, but the person must also be designated under the regulations. Medical practitioners and registered psychologists are designated (reg. s. 4(1)). Registered nurses and nurse practitioners, social workers, and occupational therapists are designated only after completing a capacity assessment course under the capacity assessment coordinator (reg. s. 4(2)). Before a formal assessment is arranged, confirm the person is designated for it.

An assessment under this Act is not the legal test for a will, a power of attorney, or a personal directive. A report may be useful evidence, but it does not by itself decide whether a document is valid. The Act also treats a representation order as a last resort, and the Office of the Public Trustee notes that where an enduring power of attorney or personal directive already exists, an application is often unnecessary.

Warning signs that call for professional advice

None of these proves incapacity, but each is a reason to get advice before anything is signed.

  • A sudden change to long-standing intentions, especially where a new adviser, caregiver, or beneficiary has appeared.
  • Difficulty giving even a general account of what the person owns, who their family is, or what the document is for.
  • Understanding that comes and goes, or a change since a hospital stay, an infection, or a bereavement.
  • Someone else arranging the appointment, steering the conversation, or answering on the person’s behalf.
  • Instructions that shift depending on who is in the room, or an existing document replaced in a hurry.

A diagnosis settles nothing on its own.

Keeping the person in charge

Supported decision-making starts from the idea that most people can decide for themselves with help. Ask what the person wants before anyone explains what is usually done. Offer practical aid: a written list of assets, large print, a quiet room, an interpreter, a second appointment at a better hour. Let the person speak for themselves, and be willing to leave the room so instructions can be given privately. Do not correct their choices; a decision that looks unwise to you is not evidence of incapacity.

If you rehearse answers or supply names, the professional cannot tell what the person understands. Ask open questions, allow silence, and check understanding by asking the person to explain the document back in their own words.

Avoiding pressure and undue influence

Undue influence is a separate question from capacity, and it can defeat a document even where the person understood it. Use an independent professional and let them control the process. Do not sit in on the instructions if you are a beneficiary, and say your own interest out loud at the start. Resist deadlines invented by the family; very few estate documents cannot wait a week.

Practical steps before anything is signed

  • Gather the facts: assets, existing documents, deeds, and the people involved.
  • Book the appointment for the person’s best time of day.
  • Describe how the person is functioning day to day, not the label on a medical file.
  • Raise your concern with the professional beforehand, so safeguards can be arranged rather than improvised.
  • Choose witnesses carefully. For a will, two competent witnesses together, with the signature made or acknowledged before them and both signing in the maker’s presence; a gift to a witness or a witness’s spouse is void, though the will itself stands, and the gift survives if there are two other competent witnesses (Wills Act, ss. 6, 12). For a power of attorney, two competent adults who are neither the appointed attorney nor the attorney’s spouse, registered domestic partner, common-law partner, or child (s. 3). For a personal directive, one eligible adult witness who is neither a delegate nor a delegate’s spouse, nor a person signing for the maker or that person’s spouse (s. 3).
  • Keep a short record: the date, who was present, and how the person explained the document.

You cannot certify capacity, and neither can a helper’s opinion, however well informed. That determination belongs to the professional preparing the document and, where warranted, to a qualified clinician or designated assessor.

If capacity is no longer there

If the person can no longer make the decision, the answer is not for a family member to sign on their behalf, or to write a document reflecting what the family assumes they wanted. Look first at what exists: an enduring power of attorney or personal directive may still do the work. If there is nothing in place, a representation order is the court route, and the Office of the Public Trustee publishes the forms and guides, including help with assessment costs.

Start early, plan calmly

Keep the person at the centre, put good supports in place, and involve an estate planning professional while there is still room to think. A document prepared that way is better for the person signing it, and harder for anyone to challenge later.

Book an Appointment in Halifax or Dartmouth