A handwritten page and fountain pen on a wooden desk

After a death, a family finds a sheet of paper in a desk drawer. In familiar handwriting, it says who should inherit the house and who should look after the estate. It is signed, but there are no witnesses. The family has two questions: did the person make a valid will, and can they prove it to the Probate Court? In Nova Scotia, those are separate questions.

A handwritten will can be valid without witnesses. The simplest way to understand the rule is to think about what witnesses usually help establish: who signed the document and whether it was signed as a will. When there are no witnesses, the family may need other evidence after the person who could best explain it has died. That is one reason a handwritten will can look easier to make than it is to use.

What counts as a holographic will?

A holographic will is a will written wholly in the will-maker’s own handwriting and signed personally by that person. Section 6(2) of Nova Scotia’s Wills Act allows that kind of will without witnesses. A document typed on a computer, even by the will-maker, does not become a holographic will just because the signature is handwritten. If a printed or typed template supplies part of the will’s wording, plan to follow the ordinary witnessed signing rules rather than relying on the handwritten-will exception.

For an ordinary witnessed will, the will-maker signs at the end, or directs someone else to sign there in the will-maker’s presence. The will-maker makes or acknowledges the signature with at least two witnesses together. The witnesses then sign in the will-maker’s presence. Those are the usual signing rules; they are different from the rules for a holographic will.

Handwriting and a signature answer the question of signing formalities. They do not settle everything else. The writer must have the capacity to make a will, intend the document to govern what happens after death, and make the decisions freely. A handwritten list of ideas about future gifts may be exactly that: a list of ideas. Even a signed note may leave others wondering whether it was meant to be final. Conversely, a document does not need elaborate legal language to express a clear decision.

Why Nova Scotia recognizes handwritten wills

Nova Scotia introduced general recognition of holographic wills on August 19, 2008. In its 2003 final report on the Wills Act, the Law Reform Commission of Nova Scotia recommended adopting the approach already taken in several other Canadian jurisdictions. The reasons included simplicity, greater consistency and giving effect to someone’s wishes when there was good evidence of what they intended.

There was a trade-off. Letting someone make a will without arranging witnesses removes a barrier at the time they write it. It also removes evidence the family could otherwise use later. Nova Scotia addressed that by adopting a separate probate procedure for proving the handwriting and signature. The rule is available outside emergencies, but it is most valuable when arranging a conventional signing is genuinely difficult or impossible in the time available.

When is a handwritten will worth considering?

Imagine someone in hospital who wants to put a clear decision in writing and cannot arrange a witnessed signing in time. Or imagine someone temporarily isolated who has no will and wants to record a straightforward plan. In either situation, a handwritten will may be a practical option if the person can write and sign it themselves and has the capacity and intention to make it. Being in hospital does not by itself establish or rule out capacity.

If there is time to obtain advice and arrange a witnessed will, that is usually the better choice. Consider a parent who writes, “I leave my house to my daughter.” That may sound clear, but what if the parent no longer owns the house at death? Who gets the rest of the estate? What if the daughter dies first? Who will take responsibility for administering the estate? A professionally prepared will can address those questions before the family has to guess.

Extra care is warranted if there is a previous will, a blended family, real estate held with someone else, a dependant who needs ongoing support, or property with its own beneficiary designation. A will does not control every asset someone thinks of as theirs to leave. Even what seems like a simple change to a single gift can leave conflicting instructions if an earlier will remains in the picture. Don’t assume an informal note will do exactly what you intended alongside existing documents.

How the family proves the handwriting

Probate is the court process that can establish the will and the authority of the person administering the estate. For a routine application involving a holographic will, Nova Scotia’s probate regulations require an affidavit called Form 2A. An affidavit is a sworn or affirmed statement. The person making it must be well acquainted with the will-maker’s handwriting and signature, having frequently seen the person write and sign. They examine the document and say whether they believe both the writing and the signature are the will-maker’s.

The person giving this evidence does not have to have watched the will being made. A relative, friend or colleague may be able to help if they actually know the handwriting and signature well enough. Familiarity with the signature alone is not enough to identify the rest of the document. Nor does the person administering the oath supply the handwriting evidence merely by signing the affidavit. Those are different roles.

The original will must be attached to the Form 2A and identified as an exhibit. The affidavit can be made at or after the time the will is signed, before or after the will-maker’s death. That can matter if the person best able to identify the handwriting is elderly, ill or likely to become hard to reach. For comparison, in a routine probate application for an ordinary witnessed will, one of the people who witnessed it normally gives evidence in Form 2.

An affidavit is evidence for the application. It is not what makes the will valid, and it does not guarantee that the court will grant probate. If the original is available but nobody can honestly give the prescribed handwriting evidence, don’t ask someone to guess or assume the rules for ordinary witnessed wills will apply. Ask a Nova Scotia estate lawyer what evidence and court process may be appropriate in that case.

What if the document is incomplete, altered or missing?

If the writing does not meet the usual signing rules, a court has limited discretion under section 8A of the Wills Act to give effect to a writing that embodies the deceased’s intentions about their will. That is a court decision based on the evidence, not a way of overlooking a mistake at the probate counter. The availability of that remedy is no reason to plan on needing it.

If the original is lost or destroyed, the issue is different from having the original but no one who knows the handwriting. Under section 69 of the probate regulations, the usual route is to apply to prove the will’s validity and contents in solemn form under section 31 of the Probate Act, unless the court orders otherwise. That is a formal court process for establishing the will. A copy may help, but it is not a substitute that automatically gets accepted. The circumstances in which the original went missing can matter, including whether the person may have destroyed it intending to revoke it.

An undated handwritten will is not automatically invalid just because there is no date. Still, a date can help establish which document came first if more than one set of instructions is found. Later changes can create similar trouble. A sentence added below an existing signature, or a name crossed out after signing, may not have the effect the writer intended. If you want to change a will you have already signed, get advice rather than editing the original by hand.

Practical steps for the will-maker and the family

If you are thinking about making a handwritten will, first ask whether you can arrange a witnessed signing. If there simply isn’t time, get professional advice as soon as circumstances allow. Think about who should handle the estate, what should happen to any property not specifically mentioned, and what should happen if a person you name dies before you. Keep the original safe and tell the person who will need it where it is. When a witnessed will becomes practical, revisit the handwritten document rather than leaving both in circulation without advice.

If you find a handwritten will after a death, preserve it as it is. Don’t write on it or make repairs. Note where and when it was found, keep any envelope or other relevant papers, and locate any earlier wills without destroying anything. Identify people who genuinely knew the writer’s handwriting and signature. If there’s only a copy, conflicting versions, or doubt about what the writer meant, seek advice before treating the document as authority to deal with the estate.

The handwritten-will rule gives people a way to make their intentions count when a witnessed signing isn’t practical. When there is time to plan, a clear, properly witnessed will usually gives the family the easier document to administer and prove.

This article provides general information about Nova Scotia law, not advice on any particular will.

Book an Appointment in Halifax or Dartmouth